On the nice list are definitely William, Sameth, Tumnus and Jane. I'm not sure if Jane will be around for the holidays but lovely paper for writing on would make her happy.

William-a stack of dime novels.
Sameth-a clockwork toy
Tumnus-a new teapot

I love this plot, its just so charming. Also the illustrations remind me of these books I had growing up about Father Christmas. They were from England and about him going on vacation and just cute.